25 Caribbean Islands For Travelers Who Crave Peace

Escape the noise and forget the usual tourist traps. If you’re the type who would rather stroll along a secluded beach than fight for space at a popular hotspot, these 25 Caribbean islands are the perfect antidote to all the chaos. No overpriced cocktails or Instagram influencers here, as these are just pure, unspoiled beauty.

Cayo Espanto

Cayo Espanto, a teensy private island near Ambergris Caye, is as exclusive as it gets. Each overwater villa is its own secluded haven, complete with plunge pools and panoramic sea views. The staff delivers your meals by boat. You won’t find beach bars or tourist shops here—only serenity served on a silver tray.

Petit St. Vincent

Imagine signaling your room service request by hoisting a yellow flag outside your cottage; that’s how it works on Petit St. Vincent. This 115-acre island has no TVs, no phones, and barely any Wi-Fi. Guests roam barefoot through rainforest trails and dine al fresco under the stars.

Guana Island

Guana Island doesn’t have a marina, which means no yacht parties interrupt the stillness. It was once a sugarcane plantation, which now preserves its wildness with hiking paths through bird-filled hills and protected reefs for snorkelers.

Caye Caulker

Don’t expect to rush anything on Caye Caulker, as this place has cherished the art of doing nothing with flair. You’ll find sandy streets, golf carts instead of cars, and reggae floating through the salty air. Locals hang out at “The Split,” a channel that divides the island, perfect for people-watching.

Saba

Saba’s dramatic cliffs and lush rainforests set the stage for a tranquil getaway. This volcanic island offers some of the best hiking in the Caribbean, where you can explore diverse ecosystems before relaxing with stunning views of the turquoise sea.

Dominica

What makes Dominica stand apart is its unfiltered nature. Here, waterfalls burst from jungle cliffs, steaming sulfur springs bubble in hidden valleys, and centuries-old trails wind through cloud forests. Forget beach lounging—Dominica invites you to explore and soak beneath rainforest canopies.

Bequia

Bequia’s history is tied to boat-building, and you’ll still spot handmade vessels bobbing in Admiralty Bay. The island moves to the rhythm of tide and tradition, with harborside fish markets. You can sip passionfruit cocktails at a bar with no name or chat with artists painting from seaside porches.

La Desirade

Step off the beaten path onto La Desirade, where the air smells of salt and freedom. It’s the kind of place you stumble upon and then never want to leave. Wind-swept plateaus give way to pebbled coves, and goats wander lazily through town.

Little Corn Island

This island is the Caribbean’s best-kept secret. With no cars and a relaxed pace of life, Little Corn Island’s laid-back atmosphere makes it a perfect escape. Spend your days diving with vibrant marine life or simply unwinding in pure serenity.

Cayos Cochinos

Cayos Cochinos is an untouched paradise with pristine waters and abundant marine life. This archipelago of 13 cays is a UNESCO-protected area, perfect for those who want to disconnect from the hustle and bustle. Get away from it all—nature here thrives without disturbance.

Prickly Pear Cays

Situated in a breezy 30-minute boat ride from Anguilla, the Prickly Pear Cays are two uninhabited slices of beach bliss. These low-lying islets don’t offer much in terms of infrastructure. You might spot a makeshift beach bar open for grilled snapper and rum punch, but don’t count on it.

Saona Island

While technically part of the Dominican Republic’s national park system, Saona feels like a world of its own. Mangroves weave through its edges, and palm trees lean dramatically toward crystal-clear shallows, where starfish like to laze. Moreover, you’ll find no permanent residents here.

Ambergris Caye

Ambergris Caye is considered the largest island in Belize, offering an escape for those who love both adventure and peace. Since it is situated close to the Belize Barrier Reef, it is a diver’s paradise. Yet, despite its popularity, it still maintains an authentic, laid-back charm that feels peaceful.

Isla De Providencia

A Caribbean island that belongs to Colombia but vibes more like a floating Caribbean village—Isla de Providencia is a mystery worth unwrapping. Here, you get a place where English Creole is spoken, and the locals refer to the reef as “The Sea of Seven Colors.”

Tobago

Unlike its bigger, brasher twin, Trinidad, Tobago keeps it low-key—and that’s exactly why you’ll love it. This island thrives on folklore, fishing, and festive village life, with wooden homes perched on green hills and secret beaches waiting past winding coastal roads.

Culebra

Just a short ferry or puddle-jumper from mainland Puerto Rico, this island trades high-rises for wildlife. Flamenco Beach might be Insta-famous, but the real soul of Culebra lives in its turtle-nesting shores and roadside stands selling papaya smoothies.

Nevis

Nevis is part of the twin-island federation of St. Kitts and Nevis. Whether you’re hiking the dormant volcano of Nevis Peak or simply lounging by the quiet shore, Nevis allows you to experience Caribbean beauty without the crowds.

Montserrat

Often known as the “Emerald Isle of the Caribbean,” Montserrat is a gem that promises solitude and natural beauty. The island’s active Soufriere Hills volcano provides a beautiful backdrop. Lastly, with a population much smaller than most Caribbean islands, Montserrat’s peaceful ambiance lets you truly relax.

Carriacou

Carriacou is a small island located in the southern Caribbean, part of Grenada. Visitors can enjoy leisurely walks through its charming villages and swim or snorkel in its calm bays. Moreover, the island’s rich history, including its African heritage, is evident in the festivals, music, and dance.

Great Exuma

One of the standout experiences on Great Exuma is the opportunity to swim with the famous swimming pigs of Big Major Cay. These friendly, wild pigs wade into the waters and interact with visitors, making for an unforgettable and quirky adventure.

Barbuda

In addition to its beaches and wildlife, Barbuda offers visitors a glimpse of local culture, with the small, tight-knit community living in harmony with the island’s natural surroundings. The capital, Codrington, also has a relaxed charm, where you can explore local markets and experience the laid-back pace of island life.

Roatan

Roatan is famous for its beaches, with West Bay Beach being one of the island’s most famous. Its white sands and shallow waters are ideal for swimming and enjoying the sunshine. Lesser-known beaches like French Harbour and Little French Key also offer a more soothing experience away from the tourist-heavy spots.

Union Island

Union Island’s beaches, though not as extensive as some of the larger Caribbean islands, are still incredibly beautiful. The island’s best beaches include the quiet and serene Ashton Lagoon, where you can enjoy a peaceful swim, and the more popular Happy Island, a man-made creation from conch shells.

Holbox Island, Mexico

Just north of Mexico’s Yucatan Peninsula, Holbox (say it like “hol-bosh”) trades the resort sprawl of Cancun for barefoot wanderlust. Sandy streets are ruled by bicycles and the occasional golf cart. Come between May and September, and you might swim alongside gentle whale sharks.

St. Eustatius

St. Eustatius is a nature lover’s paradise. It is dominated by the dormant volcano, The Quill, which rises to 2,000 feet and is a must-see for those who enjoy hiking. Moreover, Statia was one of the first islands to formally recognize the United States’ independence during the American Revolution.